Skip to main content

«  View All Posts

Roof Replacement /

2024 Guide: The Cost of a New Roof - Top 7 Roofing Materials Compared

May , 2024 | 33 min. read

By Nicole Corson

Spanish tile roof

Don’t you hate it when you land on an article, read it, only to find out at the end that you need to contact someone to get the answer you were searching for? It usually goes something like this: ” to find out more information on our costs and prices, click this button to contact us.” 

Listen, we get how frustrating this can be, so we promise to not only have the difficult conversations about price but also to be transparent and provide you with as much information as we can upfront. 

The cost of having your roof replaced is a lot like purchasing a car. Many variables and options will determine the final amount needed to cover your preferences, right? 

standing metal roof on a sea foam color Florida home 

Many of the same model vehicles come with options for more horsepower, special paint, or tire and wheel packages. Do you love upgraded interior packages with a sunroof or a panoramic view? Let’s not forget about the amazing electronic packages available. 

So, do you prefer the basic model or the one with all the bells and whistles? Or maybe somewhere in between? Well, just like buying that perfect vehicle, the one that's just right for you, there are a lot of “bells & whistles' to choosing a roof that's just right for you.

two-story white home with black shingles with a one story wrap around porch that has metal roofing

Since we have helped thousands of clients over the past few decades. We decided to put our experience to work right here for you. Whether you choose to use RoofCrafters for your roofing project or another local contractor, we want to be a part of your journey and help educate and inform you so you make a better-informed decision about your upcoming roofing investment. 

Many factors go into determining the cost of a new roof, so we’ll do our best to make it easy to understand. In this article, we'll cover the 3 main factors that determine the cost. We'll show examples of the most popular roofing materials used on homes. We'll also provide you with the average cost of the top 7 roof materials used. We've also put together a short video if you'd rather watch it instead of reading the article.

Let’s get started, shall we?


Key Price Factors for New Roofing in 2024


The cost of replacing your roof varies depending on many factors, below are the 3 key factors used to determine the price.  

  1. The type of roof material you select will impact the cost.

  2. The total square footage of the roof area that needs to be covered.

  3. The complexity or difficulty of your roof project, such as, how steep your roof is.


Budget-Friendly Roofing Options: What You Need to Know


The most economical and cost-effective roofing is asphalt shingles. They offer a wide range of styles and colors. There are 4 styles of asphalt shingles for you to choose from.

Florida-style stucco home with new asphalt shingles

The 4 styles of asphalt shingles provide options depending on the particular style or curb appeal that you prefer. We found this helps keep within the budget you have set aside.

The 4 different shingle types are: 

  • 3-Tab shingles
  • Architectural shingles
  • Upgraded architectural shingles
  • Designer shingles 

Average Roof Replacement Costs in 2024


It would be impossible for me to give you an exact price without knowing all of the factors used to determine the final cost. So we'll provide you with the average cost of a typical home with one of the most popular roof materials.

stucco home with architectural shinglesMost homeowners can expect the cost of their roof to average between $11,200 and $17,100. This price is based on a typical 3 to 4-bedroom home, with a standard 2-car garage.  Installing an architectural grade shingle.

Of the asphalt shingles types, GAF Timberline HDZ shingles shown above are the most popular materials installed on residential homes. 

The price may be slightly less, but it could be a little higher. But typically it will fall somewhere in between depending on all the project-specific factors. Every home has different roofing components that are needed for your roof. Every roofing project is a little different, therefore calculating the exact cost of your roof without seeing it would be nearly impossible. 

New call-to-action

To get the exact cost for your roof you'd probably want to have your local roofing contractor come out. They can do an onsite inspection and take exact measurements.  If you are in one of our service areas and you are ready now you can schedule your inspection here.

2024’s Top 7 Roofing Materials: Costs and Comparison


The materials you choose are one of the key factors that go into calculating the cost of your roof replacement. Below is a list of the top 7 and most popular roof types and the average cost for a new roof. 

  1. 3-tab shingle roof average cost of $7,300  to  $10,600

  2. Architectural shingles average cost  $11,200  to  $17,100

  3. Upgraded architectural shingle average cost of $13,100  to  $19,000

  4. Designer shingle roofs average cost of $18,300  to  $29,100

  5. Screw-down metal roofs average cost of $16,500  to  $31,700

  6. Standing seam metal average costs $27,500  to  $42,300

  7. Spanish tile roof average cost  $33,700  to  $69,800

Cost of 3-tab Roofing in 2024: A Comprehensive Guide


3-Tab shingles are the least expensive and therefore will be the most economical shingles available. They come in a wide variety of colors. They also provide your home with the least protection. 

3-tab shingle

The 3-tab shingles are often referred to as "builder-grade" shingles. They are commonly installed on new construction homes and investment properties. They’re good if you have an extremely tight budget. However, they’re not so good if you are looking for the highest quality and best protection from storms.

Cost: Least expensive shingles, 3-tab average around $7,300 to $10,600.

Aesthetics: They are flat and provide a slate-like look.

Lifespan: In most climates, they will last between 12 to 15 years.

Protection: Being the lightest of the asphalt shingles they provide the least wind warranty of the 4 shingle types at only 60 mph compared to 130 mph for the other 3 options.


Single story home with 3 tab shinglesFor a 3-tab shingle roof on a home with 2 straight sides. Without chimneys or skylights, the average cost is $7,300.


two story home with 3 tab shinglesA 3-tab shingle roof on a house with 2 stories. A little more complex, the average cost is $8,950.


3 tab roof with complex valleysA 3-tab shingle on a home that is more complex. The roof has several valleys and gables, the average cost is $10,600.

 View the GAF 3-Tab colors here.

View the CertainTeed 3-Tab colors here.

Cost of Architectural Shingles in 2024: A Comprehensive Guide 


Architectural asphalt shingles are much heavier than the 3-tab shingles. They'll provide you with a better wind rating. A higher wind rating gives you more protection during strong storms.

architectural asphalt shingle


Architectural shingles are sometimes referred to as laminated or dimensional shingles.  During the production of the shingle, the manufacturer laminates shingle parts together. This laminated part creates depth or provides dimension.

Fun fact, this shingle was designed to look like real wood shingles.  So, in my opinion, the darker colors look more natural. Especially the brown colors. Maybe because they resemble a real wood shake shingle roof more than the gray colors or light gray colors. And just maybe it's because I know they were designed to look like wood shingles and wood shingles are brown!

Seafoam color stucco with cultured stone and a GAF Timberline HDZ shakewood shingle roof


The architectural shingle is also the most popular shingle used in the United States. This shingle provides a higher wind warranty and depending on weather conditions it lasts 7-10 years longer than the 3-tab shingles. 

Cost: Architectural shingles typically cost around 10% to 15% more than 3-tab shingles Average cost is $11,200  to  $17,100.

Aesthetics: These shingles provide a dimension that will provide more curb appeal.

Lifespan: Most architectural roofs last 17 to 22 years with proper roof ventilation. Why does proper ventilation matter?

Protection: With the correct installation methods they can provide wind coverage up to  130 mph depending on which manufacturer you go with.


simple architectural shingle roofAn architectural shingle on a house with 2 straight sides. Without chimneys or skylights, the average cost is $11,200.


architectural shingle home with few valleysAn architectural shingle on a home that is a little more complex.  With a dormer and a few valleys, the average cost is $14,150.


complex architectural shingle roofAn architectural asphalt shingle on a home that's more complex. With several hips and valleys, the average cost is $17,100.

View the CertainTeed architectural colors here.

View the GAF architectural colors here.

Cost of Upgraded Architectural Shingles: A Comprehensive Guide 


Upgraded architectural shingles can provide you with the same economic ease as the other shingles. The major difference is they'll enhance your curb appeal. They're heavier and thicker. 

GAF HDZ & GAF UHDZ side-by-side visual comparrison

Side by side with its little brother the ‘regular’ architectural shingle,  there is not much comparison. This shingle is made with more asphalt.  The added definition gives your roof more of a 3-dimensional look. This will boost your home's curb appeal. 


two-story home with a new GAF Timberline UHDZ shingle in Pewter gray

 It’s common sense. A heavier shingle will have less of a chance to blow off.  These shingles also come with longer algae warranties. That means the black streaks won't be able to grow on your roof for a very long time. Bonus, because it will look better for longer without the black streaks. 

Yes, It does have a greater upfront investment.  It'll also stay on longer during a high wind storm and it provides your home with much more curb appeal.  If you don't want a basic shingle roof or the most common shingle roof on the block, this is a great investment.

Cost: The upfront investment for these heavier architectural shingles is typically 10 to 15% more than the regular architectural shingles. The average cost is  $13,100  to  $19,000.

Aesthetics: The thickness of these shingles creates a very noticeable difference that provides an extra pop from the street.

Lifespan: Created with more asphalt in the shingle, these shingles typically last 25 to 30 years.

Protection: The heavier a product the less likely it is to blow off in a major wind storm. These shingles can weigh as much as 100 lb per square foot more than regular architectural shingles depending on the manufacturer you go with.


simple upgraded architectural shingleFor an upgraded architectural shingle on an easy roof pitch. With 2 straight sides and no chimneys or skylights, the average cost is $13,100.


slightly complex, upgraded architectural shingle roofAn upgraded architectural shingle on a roof that is a little more complex. With a skylight and several hips and valleys, the average cost is $16,050.


Upgraded architectural shingle on complex roofAn upgraded architectural shingle on a house with 2 or 3 stories.  The roof is more complex, with dormers and walls and several valleys, the average cost is $19,000.

View the CertainTeed shingle colors here.

View the GAF upgraded shingle colors here. 

Cost of Designer Asphalt Shingles: A Comprehensive Guide


Designer Shingles are also referred to as luxury shingles. Designer or luxury shingles are specially designed to simulate real products. Real products like slate or wood shingles. Designer or luxury shingles are specially designed to add a unique one-of-a-kind look to your house.

GAF Woodlawn designer shingle roof on custom brick home

Designers are the heaviest in the asphalt family. Because of the extra weight, these shingles will certainly be the last to blow off during a high wind storm. Designer shingles can add tremendous aesthetic value, they'll provide your home with a stellar curb appeal with their one-of-a-kind unique designs.

Designer Shingles

If you want your home to stand out from the rest of the homes in your neighborhood....this may be the right roof material for you!

Cost: Designer roofs have the most upfront investment and will cost anywhere from 20% to 25% more depending on which designer shingle you choose. The average cost is $18,300  to  $29,100.

Aesthetics: These shingles are specifically manufactured to provide the most curb appeal.

Lifespan: You can expect these shingles to last 30 to 40 years.

Protection: Designer shingles are the heaviest of the shingle family.  With the proper installation, these provide unmatched wind and protection from severe storms.


simple designer asphalt shingle roofFor a designer asphalt shingle on a house with an easy roof pitch.  Without chimneys or skylights, the average cost is $18,300.


designer midA designer asphalt shingle on a complex house with 2 stories or split level.  With a chimney or a skylight and valleys, the average cost is $23,700.


large home with designer asphalt shingles

A designer asphalt shingle roof on a house with 2 stories or split level.  More complex, with a chimney, dormers, and several valleys, the average cost is $29,100.

See the CertainTeed designer styles and colors here.

See the GAF designer options and colors here.

3 Things to Consider When Choosing an Asphalt Shingle 


  1. Do they fit my budget? 

  2. How long will they last?

  3. What type of maintenance will be required?

1. The Cost of the Materials


When considering the different roof materials available today, asphalt shingles are the most economically priced for any home or business. The ease of installation, combined with the 4 different grades of shingles make them appealing and a cost-efficient option for roofing any home or business.

2. The Expected Lifespan of Asphalt Shingles


  • 3-Tab asphalt shingles can be expected to last 12 to 15 years

  • Architectural asphalt shingles can be expected to last 18 to 23 years

  • Upgraded architectural asphalt shingles can be expected to last 25 to 30 years

  • Designer asphalt shingles can be expected to last 30 to 40 years

All shingles come with manufacturers' material warranties that are pre-determined by each of the manufacturers through research and studies. The expected lifespan provided above is all based on the actual lifespans that we have seen over the past 30 years in the roofing industry.

3. Roof Maintenance Can Extend the Expected Lifespan


Having roof maintenance done twice or even once per year will help prevent premature roof failure. Preventative maintenance, such as keeping leaves and debris off the roof and checking all your pipe penetrations and flashings to ensure they are properly sealed. 

red arrows pointing at leaf debris in valleys on a roof of a home

These simple tasks will prevent the most common roof leaks and extend the life of the asphalt shingles.


What Are the Pros and Cons of an Asphalt Shingle Roof?


The pros of an asphalt shingle:

  • Weather-resistant, fire-resistant, and wind-resistant. Asphalt shingles are proven to resist sunlight, heat, cold, water, and ice. They also comply with fire and wind standards.

  • Economical, easy to install, and low maintenance. Asphalt shingles are produced at a high volume, which reduces the cost compared to other roofing materials. Combine the ease of installing an asphalt shingle roof with little to no maintenance and this makes it one of the most economical roof materials available today.

  • Aesthetics and style options You get a wide selection to choose from.


The cons of an asphalt shingle:

  • Replace more often. Being the most economical, they lower lifespan than other products such as metal, slate, or clay tiles, which means they will need to be replaced more often.

  • Less protection. Asphalt shingles also have a lower wind rating than metal, slate, or clay tile roofing materials, making them more likely to get 

Now that you know all about asphalt shingles let’s talk metal roofing.

The Asphalt Shingle Color Guide

3 Popular Metal Materials Used for Roof Replacements


The 3 metal roof materials that are most commonly installed on homes and businesses in the US over the past 30+ years. 

  • Aluminum
  • Steel
  • Galvalume

The 3 different metal materials are the most economical. Which means they'll be cost-effective. They offer you a wide range of aesthetic looks, longevity, and price ranges.

These metals are available in standing seam panels, panels with exposed fasteners, or a shingle-style profile.

Aluminum Metal Roofing


Brick and stucco home with brown aluminum standing seam metal roof

Aluminum is one of the most naturally energy-efficient metal roof materials. It is highly reflective, fire-resistant, and non-corrosive. So, if you live on or near the ocean or saltwater this is a great choice of metal material because it will not rust.

Aluminum metal comes in different thicknesses; typically, we use a 032, 040, or 050 thickness for roofing. The higher the number the thicker the aluminum will be. 032 and 040 are most widely used on roofs

large home with colonial red, aluminum standing seam metal roof

Aluminum also comes in a mill finish or a painted finish. Mill finish will provide you with a raw metal look and it will oxidize into a naturally beautiful raw metal finish. Aluminum also comes in a wide variety of painted finished colors. Most of the paint finishes come with a 40-year paint warranty with some manufacturers offering a 45-year paint finish warranty.

Standing seam roofs require a high skill set. To get a properly installed roof system. This roof will last you 75+ years as long as the craftsmanship is right. And because aluminum is a softer material it's a little easier for the installers to fabricate the flashings and custom metalwork needed to get a great finished roof.

Steel Metal Roof 


black steel metal standing seam roof on a beautiful home with lots of trees

Steel roofing is the most popular material used for metal roofing products. Steel metal is galvanized steel that is hot dipped or coated in a zinc coating. Steel is less costly than aluminum and can be as effective as the other metals available. 

The steel most commonly used for roofing comes in 24 gauge, 26 gauge, and 29 gauge. Don't get fooled, unlike aluminum, the lower the number the thicker the steel metal roofing will be. 

red screw-down metal roof on brick home

4 of the most widely installed steel roofing profiles installed on homes or businesses:

  • Standing seam metal panels (12”-18” wide panels)
  • Interlocking steel shingles  (slate or shake look)
  • 5-V crimp metal roofing (2-foot wide screw-down panels)
  • Maxi-rib or multi-rib panels (3-foot wide screw-down panels)

Because steel is not a non-corrosive metal, these metal roofing materials require a painted finish. Paint finish warranties range from 20 years to 45 years depending on the thickness, type of panel, and the manufacturer of the materials.

Steel metal roofing is very cost-effective and offers a wider range of prices depending on which profile you choose, the thickness of the metal, and the paint warranty the manufacturer offers. 

Galvalume Metal Roof


galvalume standing seam on home with board and batten siding

Galvalume metal is also a metal that has a steel core and is coated with aluminum to prevent corrosion. Galvalume is much like steel roofing and comes in the same thicknesses, 24 gauge, 26 gauge, or 29 gauge. It is also available in all 4 of the different panel profiles.

stucco home with 2 car garage and a galvalume metal roof

The main difference with galvalume is that it comes as a mill-finish metal product, so it does not get a painted finish. This makes it slightly less expensive and easier to work with as the painted materials can get scratched during installation if not handled carefully. It is also a great option to use around the ocean or if you live anywhere near saltwater. 

Which Metal Roof Materials Are Right for You?


Which metal roof is right for your home? Great question! When deciding which metal roofing to choose for your home or business consider these factors;

  • Longevity
  • Durability
  • Wind Resistance
  • Maintenance 
  • Tree coverage
  • Energy efficiency
  • Desired Curb Appeal

The Cost to Roof a House With a Screw-Down Metal 


A screw-down metal roof is also referred to as an exposed fastener roof, an agricultural panel, a 5-V crimp roof, a maxi-rib, or a multi-rib panel. The screw-down roof is designed to give you the look and feel of a metal roof.  

5V crimp  metal roof showing exposed screws


Exposed fastener roofing requires less labor to install than a standing seam metal roof system. However, the exposed screws will require maintenance somewhere between 5 and 10 years. 


simple screw down metal roofFor a screw-down metal on a house with 2 straight sides.  Without chimneys, skylights, or valleys the average cost is $16,500.


screw down metal roof home with dormersA screw-down metal roof on a home with 2 stories.  A little more complex, with a chimney, dormers, and a couple of valleys, the average cost is $22,750.


large home with screw down metal roofA screw-down metal roof on a house with 2 or 3 stories.  More complex, with a chimney, walls, and several valleys, the average cost is $31,700.

View screw-down metal roof colors here.

The Cost Replace a Roof With a Standing Seam Metal 


Unlike the screw-down roof system, there is little to no roof maintenance needed for a standing seam metal roof. A standing seam metal roof is one of the best roofs. It may be the top roof option available for any home or business.

up close photo of a red standing seam roof with a chimney and 2 sun-tunnel skylights

And yes, as you can see from the figures below, this roof installation comes with a much higher upfront investment. Because standing seam metal roofing is the highest quality for metal roof systems.

One of the reasons is that superior installation methods require skilled metal roofers.  The installation goes much slower than with a screw-down metal roof system. Standing seam metal installed correctly will provide your property with the highest wind protection around.


simple standing seam metal roofFor a standing seam metal roof on a house with 2 straight sides. Without chimneys, skylights, or valleys the average cost is $27,500.


standing seam metal roof with valleysA standing seam metal on a house with a roof that is a little more complex.  Has a couple of hips and valleys, and the average cost is $34,900.


large home with red, standing seam metal roofA standing seam metal roof on a house with 2 or 3 stories.  More complex, with a chimney, walls, a skylight, and several valleys, the average cost is $42,300.

View the Standing Seam metal roof colors here.

The Cost to Tear-Off and Replace a Tile Roof


A tile roof or tile roofing is sometimes referred to as a Spanish roof or a Spanish roofing tile.  It's one of the premium roof materials available today.  

Multi-colored clay tile roof

Tiles are made from clay or concrete materials. The cost of concrete tiles vs. clay tiles is similar. Both tiles are designed for longevity and to appeal to a certain architectural design. Typically these are installed on Mediterranean, European, Modern, and of course Spanish-style homes.

Because of the weight of tile roofs, your home or business needs to be pre-engineered for a tile roof. The average weight of a tile roof is 1000 pounds per square.


simple tile roofFor a tile roof on a house with 2 straight sides. Without chimneys, skylights, or valleys the average cost is $33,700.


tile roof with multiple valleysA tile roof on a more complex home with 2 stories or split level.  the roof has several hips and valleys, the average cost is $51,750.


large home with tile roof that has multiple valleysA tile roof on a complex house with 2 or 3 stories.  With a chimney, walls, or a skylight and several hips and valleys, the average cost is $69,800.

To see roof tile types and colors available, view Eagle styles and colors here

Can You Afford the New Roof You Want?


Yes, you can! You can estimate the replacement costs on your own, but getting in contact with a professional roofing company will always be best. They'll be able to catch all the details needed to complete an entire roofing system and give you an in-depth explanation.  You can also use our pricing calculator tool to help you get a rough idea of your roof cost, it's free!

Image call to action, use the pricing calculator to estimate the cost of your roof replacement

When it comes down to how much you can expect to pay for a new roof, and if you can afford it, any reputable roofing company will offer you financing options so you can stay within your budget. Ready to begin your roof replacement journey? Click the Schedule an Inspection button below.

Schedule an Inspection

If you'd prefer to brush up a little more on your roofing service knowledge, you can better educate yourself through the extensive resources located in our learning center. We recommend you read: Weathering the Storm: Understanding the Top Challenges Roofing Companies Face.

Nicole Corson

At RoofCrafters, our mission is to provide job opportunities for others to thrive and grow while making a meaningful impact within our communities.