Skip to main content

«  View All Posts

Roof Repair /
Roof Replacement

Is it Time for a Roof Repair or Replacement in St Augustine, FL?

July , 2023 | 7 min. read

By David Toth

2 roofers wearing safety gear repairing a roof

St Augustine, FL is no stranger to coastal weather conditions, which inevitably result in the gradual wearing out of our roofs over time. Despite regular upkeep and inspections, a point will come when a roof replacement becomes a necessity. Choosing between a simple repair and a comprehensive roof replacement can be a tough call.

As a homeowner in St. Johns County, you have plenty on your plate. So, why not let the experts assist with the roofing decisions?

We understand this is a significant decision, so we'll do our best to simplify it for you. At RoofCrafters, we have over 30 years of experience in roof repairs and replacements across Florida. We're thrilled you're here to discover whether your roof needs repairing or if it's time for a complete overhaul.  We're also eager to share our insights with you.

man drinking coffee inside with an umbrella, pots and pans catching roof leaks

In this article, we'll help you understand when a roof repair may be all that's needed. When a replacement might be imperative, and the factors that can influence these decisions. Additionally, feel free to take our free 'repair or replace my roof' quiz below.

Ready? Let's dive in!

Should You Repair or Replace Your St Augustine Roof?


roofer repairing a 3-tab shingle roof

Roofs, unfortunately, are not immortal. We'd all wish for our roofs to be impervious to time and weather. Thus staving off significant home improvement tasks. But, each roof has a finite lifespan, and after reaching its zenith, a roof replacement is unavoidable. Even though certain roofing materials may be more durable and outlast others. A total roof replacement will one day be necessary.

A flat roof being installed by a roofer

But, it's possible that your roof only requires minor repairs to rejuvenate it and extend its life. Several factors can influence the decision between repairing or replacing your roof. 

Let's discuss 7 key factors to consider:

  1. Age of the Roof: The age of your roof is a crucial consideration. Most roofs have a lifespan of 20-30 years. If your roof is within this age range, it might be more cost-effective to replace it rather than repair it.
  2. The Extent of Damage: Minor damages like a few missing shingles or a small leak could be fixed with a simple repair. Yet, severe damages or widespread leaks might need a full replacement.
  3. Roofing Material: The kind of roofing material also affects your decision. Some materials, like tile or metal, have longer lifespans than asphalt shingles or wood shakes.
  4. Costs: Assess the cost of repairs against the cost of a new roof. If the repair costs approach or exceed a third of the price of a new roof, replacement might be a more prudent option.
  5. Future Plans: If you're planning to stay in your house for an extended period, investing in a new roof could prove more beneficial. Yet, if you're planning to sell your house soon, a repair might suffice.
  6. Energy Efficiency: Modern roofing systems often provide superior insulation and energy efficiency. If your existing roof isn't energy-efficient, replacing it could reduce your energy bills in the long run.
  7. Local Weather: Coastal areas like St Augustine are prone to extreme weather conditions. So, the type and condition of your roof can impact its durability.

Image call to action, take the repair or replace quiz

Persistent Leaks and Storm Damage: Signs Your Roof in St Augustine Needs Attention


Routine maintenance and minor repairs are all part of the package when owning a home in St Augustine But, if you find yourself patching up leaks. It might feel more like you're trying to hold a crumbling dam together with duct tape — not exactly a permanent solution.

roofers removing a flat deck roof with rotten plywood

We understand that persistent roof leaks are an inconvenience. But they also point towards deeper issues that could threaten your roof's structural integrity. They might show errors in installation or deterioration of the roofing material. It's important to consult with a reliable local roofing company in such cases. An expert roofer can carry out a comprehensive inspection to identify the problem. They'll be able to recommend the most suitable course of action, saving you time, money, and a lot of stress.

roofer tearing off a roof with rotten plywood decking

Visible signs of damage are not confined to your roof's exterior. Often, severe problems reveal themselves indoors, on your ceilings, or in the attic, beneath the roof's wooden decking. Repeated sagging, discoloration, or peeling paint on your ceiling might be a roof leak. If left unaddressed, these issues can cause significant damage. Which could lead to a complete roof replacement.

rooftop shot of missing shingles and Jacksonville RoofCrafters truck

External signs of wear, such as extensive granule loss on your roof's surface, can shorten the lifespan of your shingles. If neglected, this could lead to serious leaks that damage your home's interior.

loose cracking shingles in a metal valley

In our coastal climate, a compromised roof invites trouble. It allows moisture, debris, and pests into your home, leading to issues that can be costly to remedy. Signs of rust on the chimney flashing or roofing nails can also suggest that your roof is failing and may need to be replaced.

roofer on flat roofing brooming off the debris

If you notice symptoms like missing granules, curled shingles, or any cracks, it's time to get your roof inspected. This way, you'll be prepared for the cost of your upcoming roofing project.

Wrapping Up: How to Decide on Roof Repair or Replacement in St Augustine, FL


Life in St Augustine can be hard on your roof, with the challenges of hot summers and tropical storms. Over time, even a meticulously maintained roof might need more than minor repairs. Deciding whether a simple fix will do, or if a total roof replacement is necessary, can be overwhelming. We understand that.

two St Augustine Sales guys smiling with the team in the background doing field training

Regardless of the type of roofing material, no roof lasts forever. Continuous exposure to harsh weather conditions eventually leaves its mark. In some cases, a straightforward repair might suffice to extend its lifespan. Other times, a complete overhaul is the only solution.

With over three decades of experience serving the St Augustine community. RoofCrafters is here to help guide you through these tough decisions. Our deep understanding of local climate and previous roofing challenges puts us in the perfect position to assist you. We believe that helping you understand when to repair or replace your roof is key to maintaining your home. To get started on making this important decision, click the button below.

David Toth

My name is David Toth and I am the lead estimator in North Florida with RoofCrafters Roofing. Originally from New Brunswick, I have called Florida home for the past 47 years. I enjoy cooking along with traveling to different historical areas in Florida when I have free time.