Skip to main content

«  View All Posts

DIY vs. Professional Roof Replacement

April , 2023 | 6 min. read

By Macie LaCau

Replacing your roof is one of the most significant projects you'll ever tackle on your home, and it requires patience, time, and a whole lot of skill. While not experts, some folks do have some of the knowledge needed to complete simple roof repairs. However, completing an entire roof replacement with no professional help and guidance is risky for various reasons.

 If your roof needs replacing, usually, the first step is contacting a professional roofer to help you begin the process. Roofing experts aren't just there for looks- they are vital in turning an old and dangerous roof into a brand new one that lasts for years to come. In comparison, a professional that's worked in the roofing industry for many years is recommended over your Uncle Joe or yourself when roofing matters are involved. 

But why?  We're overjoyed that you stopped by because RoofCrafters has been a trusted name in roofing for almost thirty years. When you've been on roofs day in and day out for nearly three decades, they teach you a few things. While DIY roofing can be a fantastic way to save a few bucks, it comes with risks. And while taking risks is a healthy part of life, you may want to think twice before doing so on your roofing system. 

In this article, we've made the comparison between professional and DIY roofing comprehensible so anyone can easily decide between the two. Making choices regarding large areas of our homes is often tricky and time-consuming, so we're happy to break it down a bit more just for you. If you're ready to begin, so are we!

DIY and Professional Roof Replacement: What's the Difference?    

 

You know how sometimes you spend a lot of time making a culinary dish delicious, but it still doesn't taste as great as the restaurant's version of it? Home improvement is similar- you can watch a YouTube video and buy all the tools and equipment you need, but it still may not turn out like the crisp work of a professional. There are several key factors to consider when comparing a DIY roof replacement with one performed by an expert roofer.

Bring Out Your Wallet

 

We know one of the top reasons homeowners attempt to DIY a roof replacement is to save money. It may not save as much as you think it will, though. Roofing professionals have a lot of equipment that helps them complete tasks efficiently and not get hurt, so you'll also have to buy that equipment. You'll also have to fork over money for materials, tools, and much more. If your project fails, you may even have to start from scratch by hiring a roofer to fix your botched installation job. If you're on a budget, hiring a local roofer may really save you money, especially if your DIY replacement is likely to fail. 

wallet with cards

Quality of Work

 

One major setback of performing your roof replacement is that you won't get that professional-style look or installation. You could research and watch as many tutorials as you'd like, but if you aren't an expert, you still run the risk of doing a lousy job. Some repairs are simple fixes that many could do, but when you're thinking about an entire roof replacement, you have to ensure you have experience. Now isn't the time to test the waters of your new roofing project- save that for much smaller tasks. Local roofers are held to a high standard when installing roofs, meaning they have to do a great job or they have to fix it. Top roofers also undergo rigorous training and certifications that make them the best at what they do. 

roofers installing a screw-down metal roof off a ladder

Hen Gone Haywire 

 

Let's be honest- if you don't know what you're doing with a project as large as this, a lot can go wrong. From mishandled parts to materials not being installed correctly to you being hurt, there's a lot at stake here. What may bring you a sigh of relief when hiring a professional is they basically do everything for you. From assessments to transporting materials to installation, they spend their days making your life easier. All that hard work, training, and earning top certifications aren't just for anything- they do it for you. 

roofer3

Danger, Danger, Danger 

 

Hopping on your roof may sound like an easy task, but it isn't. Professional roofers wear special gear and have specific equipment that helps them maneuver around roofs safely. As a DIYer, you'll either have to buy the equipment yourself (which is costly) or try to wing it and hope for the best. While we're always down for a good time, there are more fun ways to spend the day off than hurling from your roof. Please don't die. 

mikael-seegen-jX6WXNkvsPs-unsplash

Warranty? Think Again 

 

One of the beautiful parts of hiring a professional roofer is they offer a workmanship warranty. This is basically a seal of protection for you as a homeowner, and it lets you know the roofer stands by their labor and installation for years down the line. The warranty clearly states what's protected, covered, and not covered. When replacing your roof on your own, the only guarantee you may have is an invisible one because you aren't a roofing professional. This means if you mess up, you'll have to either fix what is broken even more than before or just call a roofer, which could've been done in the first place! 

lifetime warranty sign

Should I Call a Professional for My Roof Replacement?  

 

In most cases, hiring a skilled professional is your best bet. When you're faced with decisions involving something as significant and essential as your roofing system, they can't be taken lightly. Finding an expert roofer will make all the difference when it comes to a total replacement because they have the experience needed to do a spectacular job. They'll assess your roof, help you develop a plan, and work on giving you the roof you've always wanted. 

If you're curious about what else to consider before replacing your roof, check out our learning center. There, you'll find articles we've tackled on everything involving roofing, from good/bad roofers, how warranties work, and more! There's a little something for every reader, so it's a must if you want to brush up on your knowledge or help yourself get informed on roof replacements. 

image call to action, download the top 10 checklist

Alright, you made it! If you have any more questions or concerns regarding your roof and DIYs, RoofCrafters is delighted to assist you. Before you get in contact with a roofer, though, please take a quick look at our comprehensive roofer checklist to ensure you know which ones stand out and will make the perfect addition to your roofing project. To get in touch with one of our outstanding RoofCrafters representatives, head over to our contact page. 

Schedule an Inspection

Macie LaCau

I'm a native Georgian who spends my days nurturing my passions and embracing the quiet life. With a penchant for taking the road less traveled, I love discovering new ideas, rooting for the underdog, and taking the long way home. I enjoy spending time with family and friends, animals, and making memories.